Login

Just another Penton Media weblog

Contributor

Rich Karpinski : Covering the intersection of Web 2.0 technologies and services; IP communications and its impact on PSTNs; and new competitors and business models. RSS FEED

Archive for December 14th, 2007

Reading List: Social Platform Wars; Cisco Web 2.0; the Google Cloud; and more

- Did you know there’s an open source implementation of Google’s Open Social platform called Shindig? I didn’t. Google’s getting a hard time for pushing the release of Open Social to 2008 — but the software clearly is moving forward. But Facebook isn’t standing still…..

- Facebook has made its social network platform available for any company to license, a clear counter to Google’s Open Social initiative. Any service providers interested? Second-tier social network Beebo is basing their platform on the code. By doing that, they automatically ensure that all Facebook applications will run on their platform — voila, instant interoperability. Meanwhile, Here’s a good story on where the social network “open network” evolution is headed.

- What do the last two postings mean? The social network *platform* wars are underway. Service providers need to watch this platform competition closely and begin to make bets or align themselves among the various camps if they want to play in this area rather than see their customers jump off the telco “platform” and onto new platforms where they might find their voice needs served with just-good-enough VoIP calling. Think this has no chance of happening? Think again.

firefoxvoip.png- This Firefox extensions brings VoIP calling to your browser toolbar — you still need a provider or SIP server but it makes it easier to make a Web-initiated P2P call. You can even input a corporate server or Asterisk PBX if your enterprise is running voice over IP.

- Mobile advertising is apparently off to a slow start — but it’s early and the best practices and accepted models haven’t been discovered yet.

- A bit of news on Cisco’s Web 2.0 plans, which have been formalized into its Entertainment Operating System, still more vaporware (or revenue-vapor) than meaningful product for the networking giant.

- Business Week cover story on Google’s “cloud computing” strategy. - Scott Karp blogs “Why I Stopped Using Twitter”: Answer: consumption-overload. This will clearly be a generational-divide issue.

Digg Syndication Del.icio.us Syndication Google Syndication MyYahoo Syndication Reddit Syndication

No Comments

Related Topics: Reading List, All stories |

Google Knol — Another Shift From Content Indexer to Producer (and Full-On ‘Embrace and Extender’)


Service Provider Bottom Line: Google is using its Web market power to extend its business in new directions, a tactic it is likely to leverage as Google eyes wireless, handsets/mobile OSes and VoIP. Read on…

knol Earlier this year, Google took the (widely-noticed in some circles, under-the-radar in others) step of hosting Associated Press news content on their Web site. The move was at least in part to counter AP complaints about how Google *pointed* to their content.Regardless, it moved Google into the business of hosting content rather than just indexing it. And other sites that host AP content, most notably newspapers, found themselves competing with Google for traffic on those news stories.Google “hosts” other content as well, obviously, most notably YouTube videos but also if we broaden the definition of “hosting” email (via Gmail), documents (via Google apps) and more.Any business that relies on advertising thrives on page views — Google has the unique model that it benefits almost wherever those pages are found thanks to its AdWords and AdSense programs.

Today, Google started to move into another profitable content area — encyclopedic content — with a new beta program called Google Knol. From ReadWrite Web, a quick description:

Knols participants will write reference pages on any topic, using a Google content creation tool apparently in the works, and those pages will be highlighted in Google search results. Authors will choose whether they want ads to appear and will receive a “substantial revenue share.”

Competing Knols pages on the same topic will be judged by reader votes and the Google Search Quality process. There will be reader commenting, the ability to add additional information and more social features. It won’t be a walled garden but will live on the open web. Attribution will be substantial and Google is presumably working with high-profile topic specialists on the Knol project.

This isn’t a new idea. Wikipedia is the most obvious user generated content site, but upstarts like Mahalo and Squidoo have been creating user generated content stores as well. The screen shot above (courtesy of SearchEngineLand, which does a great job exploring this topic), gives a feel for what a Knol page will look like. Today, search on most any topic and a Wikipedia result will be near the top of the list. That may not change, but almost overnight (and apparently without the strict algorithmic approval other sites are required to meet) it will now be joined by a Google Knol entry as well. If high Google-ranking is the pixie dust for Web 2.0 businesses — and it is — than Google just sprinkled a little dust on its own already be-crowned head. Google says it won’t give Knol posts an unfair page rank advantage, but Udi Manber, Google vp of engineering in announcing the project, writes:

A knol on a particular topic is meant to be the first thing someone who searches for this topic for the first time will want to read.

That sure sounds like Knol’s will get to the top of the search heap fairly quickly. Bottom line, here’s what’s notable:

  • Google is getting deeper yet again into the content business, competing with its customers and partners
  • Google is using its market power to fend off upstarts by attempting to embrace and extend (a tactic typically attributed to Microsoft) winning business models
  • As much as Google believes in the power of the machine (algorithmic search) the power of people (original, spot-lighted content, social networks) is coming to the fore as well
  • Compete directly with Google, as Wikipedia is doing with its new search engine, and it may come back on you
  • SEOers are going to have a field day with this — though it’s hard to imagine they’ll be successful gaming such a high-profile Google project

What markets will Google try to embrace and extend next? For service providers, it’s not a big logical jump to expect Google to use its Web market power to enter the wireless spectrum, handsets/mobile OSs and VoIP (particularly the Web-initiated VoIP market via integration into its Google Apps suite) areas.

Digg Syndication Del.icio.us Syndication Google Syndication MyYahoo Syndication Reddit Syndication

No Comments

Related Topics: Google, Search, All stories |

Calendar

December 2007
M T W T F S S
« Nov   Jan »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Your Account

Subscribe

Subscribe to RSS Feed

Subscribe to MyYahoo News Feed

Subscribe to Bloglines

Google Syndication